Guide
Apprentice, employee or subbie: what each really costs
When the work outgrows one pair of hands, there are three ways to get another: put someone on wages, take on an apprentice, or bring in a subbie. Each costs differently, and the law, not the label, decides which one someone really is.
Updated · General information, not legal advice. Check your contract, the official source and, if it matters, a lawyer.
An employee
You pay a wage for their hours, and you decide how, when and where they work. On top of the wage come super, workers compensation insurance, leave and, once your wages are big enough, payroll tax. You pay them on quiet days too.
Worked out per billable hour, an employee costs a good deal more than their hourly wage. What an employee really costs per billable hour walks through the sum.
An apprentice
- An apprentice is an employee in a formal training arrangement: work, on-the-job training and study with a registered training organisation such as a TAFE. It often takes 3 to 4 years full-time (Fair Work Ombudsman).
- The apprenticeship has to be registered with your state or territory training authority, under a training contract that sets out both sides' obligations. Registration timeframes vary by state.
- Pay comes from the award, at apprentice rates. Someone who starts at 21 or older is an adult apprentice, with rates of their own. Look up the rates for your award with the Fair Work Ombudsman rather than guess.
- An apprentice is an employee, so super, workers compensation and leave apply as they do to anyone on wages.
The hidden cost is your time. Hours spent showing an apprentice how are hours you may not bill, and an early apprentice is slower. Set against that: you train someone the way you work, and a good apprentice often becomes your best tradesperson. Government incentives for employers of apprentices change from time to time; Australian Apprenticeships, on 13 38 73, can tell you what applies now.
A subcontractor
A subbie runs their own business and quotes or charges you for the work. Their rate is higher per hour than a wage, because it covers their own costs, tools and insurance, but you pay only for the work, with no leave and no quiet days. A few things still land on you:
- Super can still be owed. Employers pay super for eligible workers, including independent contractors paid mainly for their labour (ATO).
- Payroll tax can include payments to some contractors (business.gov.au).
- If your business is in building and construction and pays contractors for that work, you may have to lodge a Taxable payments annual report (TPAR) with the ATO by 28 August each year.
Who is really a contractor
Calling someone a subbie does not make them one. The Fair Work Ombudsman lists what decides it:
- how much control you have over how the work is done
- who carries the financial risk
- who supplies the tools and equipment
- whether they can delegate or subcontract the work
- how their hours are set
- whether the work is expected to go on indefinitely
Since 26 August 2024, a business that is a company (Pty Ltd) looks at the whole of the relationship: how the work is really done day to day, not only what the contract says. A sole trader or partnership in most states still looks mainly at what was agreed at the start. Either way, telling a worker they are a contractor when they are really an employee, without reasonably believing it, is sham contracting, and it is illegal.
The Fair Work Ombudsman cannot decide it for you. If someone sits close to the line, get advice before the arrangement starts.
Comparing them
| Item | Employee | Apprentice | Subcontractor |
|---|---|---|---|
| How the work is done | You decide | You decide, and teach | They decide, to the job you agreed |
| Paid on quiet days and leave | Yes | Yes | No |
| Super from you | Yes | Yes | When paid mainly for their labour |
| Workers compensation from you | Yes | Yes | Check your state scheme |
| Cost per hour | Wage plus on-costs | Apprentice rate plus on-costs | Their rate |
Whichever you choose, Crewzy keeps them on the job: employees and apprentices clock their time against it on the phone, and the Profit by job report shows what each job's labour really cost.
Sources
Official pages this guide relies on, read on 22 November 2026. Rules change; check them before you rely on anything here.